One Great Scene

Irving Thalberg once said that every great movie should have one great scene and it’s true. I thought about this quote while I watched the excellent doc Anvil! The Story of Anvil this past Friday. The tale of a metal band trying to make it twenty-plus years after their genre’s heyday proved funny, honest, and disarmingly poignant. Director Sacha Gervasi covers topics as diverse as selling out and rocking out, aging, and friendship through following the lifelong partnership of drummer Robb Reiner and Steve “Lips” Kudlow. And the soundtrack wasn’t too bad either.

Which brings me to that great scene. Gervasi covers the band during a recording session for their thirteenth album, the aptly titled “This Is Thirteen.” This may be one of the band’s most difficult moments—they are locked away in Dover (England not Delaware) with aging metal producer Chris Tsangarides. This is the perfect moment for Gervasi to really “go deep” and explore the characters.

In one scene, Lips sings over an instrumental mix, giving a so-so take of the lead vocals to title track “This Is Thirteen.” While Lips listens to the back-up tracks via headphones, we in the audience are only able to hear his off-key warbling. The effect is haunting—instead of the rock and roll posturing that we expect from this kind of band, we get the jarring lead vocals of an un-auto-tuned, un-pro-tooled man. If any scene distills the movie’s theme, this is it—a broken man singing his heart out to a soundtrack only he can hear. It’s going to the “honesty zone” as my friend makeitupscale would say. And, gosh, it feels good.

I think Gervasi is that rare documentarian whose ideas are not only pristine and well-studied, but whose footage bears him out. It’s not only a well-written thesis, these rock and roll dreamers must face reality, he supports that premise with perfect scenes that delve deep into his characters. Lips and Reiner argue with a club owner in Prague who stiffs them for their money. Lips waits outside a rock festival to meet Ted Nugent but is left empty handed. Not to mention those scenes where Gervasi shadows Lips’ crummy catering job outside Toronto.

So well etched out, these scenes of rock and roll disappointment stick. And by the conclusion, when Anvil does draw heat and gains recognition in Japan, it makes the triumph all the sweeter. Gervasi does such a good job communicating his characters’ personalities and motives, we feel as though we know—and care—about them. For those who continue to rock, no matter the obstacles, this movie is for you.

What great scenes do you remember from some great movies? Which ones stick with you and why?

8 responses to “One Great Scene

  1. This is going to sound SO dumb, but a scene that really sticks out to me is the one in Sex and the City (1) when Big tries to come out of the limo to talk to Carrie, and Samantha blocks him and just yells no. It said so much to me about how this series was about friendship, not love. (For the record, I had not watched the TV show yet.) Also, Kristen Davis’s portrayal of the protective friend was really powerful.

    When I think of that movie, I think of that scene.

    I’m sure there are FAR better examples (oh, like in Wall-E, when he’s watching the old musical and dancing along!) but that was the first one that came to mind.

  2. Hahaha, Kristan, that one totally sticks out in my mind too!

  3. writer-at-heart

    I remember comic scenes from “Annie Hall”, and some crazy scenes from “Almost Famous” with the rock band at a party. Not as great as “Gone With The Wind” and Scarlett gripping the dirt at Tara, but funny and enjoyable.

    Recently, although it’s TV: Chandra Wilson’s scene in this season’s Grey’s Anatomy’s finale when she realizes she cannot save an intern’s life. The power was cut off to the elevators so there is no way to get him to the operating room. Her acting was incredible. In a few seconds she turns from a doctor to a person who could only comfort him. Her facial expressions and acting were amazing in such a short time. Why the Emmy’s never recognize her is beyond me!

  4. The scene in Toy Story 3 where [spoiler alert] the group hold hands as they head to the incinerator [end spoiler alert] has been one of the most profound scenes from a film I have seen all year. I would venture to say it is the best scene from all three films. It left me with an emotion and imagery that will forever stick in my brain.

    • You know I haven’t seen 3 yet! Ha ha. I hope this isn’t the end of the movie-for if so I will be bawling for weeks.

      • As to not spoil further, I will not divulge any more information about the scene (I put a spoiler alert on there!). But you should see it – amazing how great the characters are despite them being fictional toys. Amazing stuff!

  5. @ Kristan: I haven’t seen the SATC movie yet, hmm, maybe I should.

    @ Writer: Well, the Emmy’s just an award after all. If an audience appreciates Chandra Wilson, which I’m sure they do, then her job is pretty much done.

  6. Pingback: On Location | When Pico Met Sepulveda (

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s