Youtube Generation

After attending a remarkably bad comedy open mic this weekend, I have realized that the future of comedy is not stand-up, instead it’s online, which is a good and a bad thing. Unlike an open mic, there are fewer uncomfortable moments. If you hate the video you can press pause, if you dislike the live comedy, you can get heckled by the stand-up, knock over a few chairs, and run out of Chuckle Hut stifling a scream. The downside to Youtube is that the comedy is not bright. This is not meant in a bad way, but if you grew up on Mel Brooks or Danny Kaye, like I did, you are in for a disappointment. The comedy I looked at for this blog article was roundly some of the worst of my life. Who are the new web 2.0 comedy entrepreneurs and what do they stand for? I scoured the internet for the profiles of some of the brightest lights out there in internet-land and found, well, not much.

First, there’s Fred nee Lucas Cruikshank, who is the second-most subscribed person on Youtube. He is sixteen years old, according to Wikipedia, and has already eclipsed Miley Cyrus in terms of an online profile. In fact, according to online gossip, soon he will be appearing in an episode of Hannah Montana. His shtick is to edit the pitch of his voice to headache high. Already he has made the leap from famous to rich, through merchandising, profit-sharing with Youtube and other means.


Full honesty, I could not get through an entire episode of Fred. The voice was just too high for me. On the positive side, I think it is quite incredible that a sixteen year old can be this motivated to market his “act.” Sure, every teenager dreams of being a star, but few spend this much time making that happen. I just wonder what pushy mother or father is behind this quest for uncharted Youtube fame, and cannot help but feel a little sorry for the guy. C’mon, you think this is all accidental? Have you watched a video of his? Explain to me how millions of people could find this entertaining.

Kevjumba is a bit older and a lot brighter than Fred. In fact, watching him spar with his more traditional Taiwanese dad in a recent interview led to many genuine LOL moments. Kevjumba may not have the capabilities of a Hollywood studio, but he has been able to mine the humor of his suburban environs with nothing more than a Handicam with ease. I have watched a couple of his videos and over time they are improving in quality, making me wonder what the future of this enterprise could be. His comedy at its best is very personal, and rightly so. A little more viral than the vlog, it exists in a realm of comedy not unlike stand-up, except, well, a bit less distant. Kevjumba is not content to talk about something that happened in his life, he will reenact it too and then invite you to be his “friend” and “rate” the quality of this experience.


Youtube comics generally live in an “anonymous by choice” environment, a comfortable home in a suburb or an apartment in Anytown, U.S.A. While it used to be comedy came from Hollywood or Burbank, now comedy is broadcast from anywhere. This is freeing but also a little depressing. There was nothing like the dream of Los Angeles. When the next comics come out of Auburn, Michigan or San Anita, Texas, will it be half as fun?

The Youtubers’ camera work is frustratingly amateur; constant jump cuts jar the viewer. The sound quality is always spotty. The acting, well, none are trained, and I have never said this before, but it shows. But who cares? The very nature of Youtube is to share lives with others, until the gap between the viewer and the viewed has shrunk enough that your fifteen minutes are their fifteen minutes of fame—reviewable for all time on small simulcast screens or iPhones. No one will die in the future, they will just lose web presence. The medium is very much the message here, and it needs constant reloading.

Most of these comics are young men, usually in their teens. Their fan base, as far as I can tell, are not other young men but, who else, teenage girls. Like any great popular phenomenon, a pack of screaming tweens is not far behind. Who is to blame them for making videos and posting them online, though? If I were sixteen in 2009 I probably would have done the same thing. Me, I did things the old fashioned way: daydreaming.

Commenters, please let me know there is intelligent life out there! Who do you subscribe to? Why?

8 responses to “Youtube Generation

  1. “There was nothing like the dream of Los Angeles. When the next comics come out of Auburn, Michigan or San Anita, Texas, will it be half as fun?”

    I dunno, maybe I’m biased because writing has always been this way, but I think it’s nice that geographically things are becoming more democratic. In terms of producing TVs or movies, people are still going to have to go to LA, but to just get noticed? It’s nice to know you don’t have just one or two cities to get your shot in.

    (PS: My grammar is awful this morning. The ole brain’s still booting up…)

  2. Kevjumba and his father are really funny and clever. They remind me of some of the old comics who worked in duos. Thanks for sharing this!
    (Fred gave me a headache, but I can see how he would appeal to some crazy high school kids.)
    Also agree with Kristan that humor can come from any location. Lots of comedy out here in the Midwest! (It makes the recession go easier…) And don’t a lot of talk show hosts come from here?

  3. When someone sends me a Youtube link, 9 times out of 10 I don’t click on it, since 9 times out of 10 I’ll be disappointed. I think at some point, basic film concepts should be taught to young kids, so as to make the new-new generation of Youtubers a little more competent in their online videos.

    Also — how pissed off is the Star Wars kid? He could have been a Youtube GOD, but his little online caper came out during the years when internet = instant rape.

  4. What kind of a wacko is that Fred?… brilliant *LMAO

  5. @ Kristan and writer-at-heart thanks for the comments. You’re right, I’m not saying the midwest isn’t funny. I totally agree. What I am wondering is why is every Youtube video recorded in a suburban basement? I would like one or two to show something other than a blank wall and a ping pong table.

  6. @ Kevin–who is Star Wars kid? I’m curious!

  7. @ Sarah–Fred reminds me of my friends in middle school! So unfortunate we were before Youtube.

  8. @John

    The Star Wars kid was essentially the “first” video uploaded on the internet to go “viral”. Noted because at the time (circa 1990s), the term viral didn’t exist and the idea of becoming internet famous was mind-boggling. It just him swinging a broom around like a Jedi idiot, but there’s a million parodies of it around.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s